Wednesday, April 22, 2009

Lou Holtz and Leadership- What does your team expect from you?

Nation,

Another summer season looms and teams and players eagerly await their tryout process. People are finishing workout programs, people are getting outside to work on throws, and advertisement for tryouts are being sent out by e-mail and posted on sites.

Every year you hear the same thing from almost every competitive team, regardless of division or city

  • We're a competitive team dedicated to winning/development
  • Our goal is to reach nationals/upas with a top x finish (Usually the goal is overestimated and never met)
  • Every spot on the team is up for grabs
  • There is always extra themes that are common for teams ("fun", "great learning experience", "serious" "young".
I think teams do a good job of explaining what they envision the team to be. The promotion of tryouts is a shot-gun approach, hanging up a proverbial shingle and hoping the right players (and lots of them) come to tryouts. Paired with some direct communication to desired player targets, this is usually an effective strategy for fielding a team.

The only problem with this overall strategy is people have heard the same message every year, and we're getting desensitized to the messages of hope, fun, and lofty performance goals. We know that not all spots on good teams is available. We know that particular skill sets are wanted, and you're wasting your money if you don't fit that mould. And we know that the tryouts are an imperfect process based on people's mind's eye making a decision on who's good and who's not.

So, what strategy changes can I suggest? One easy change to stand out among teams is when it comes to Leadership. Like all areas of life, Leadership is in desperate supply when it comes to ultimate.

Lou Holtz, former US college football coach and national champion with Notre Dame was a heavy accented odd looking man who wouldn't strike you as a great leader or a man who could lead others to greatness. However, Holtz was a man known for his wit and his character as a coach, recruiter, speaker and studio analyst.

What was the secret for this man? A lot more simple than you might think. Holtz sold players on his program and the chance to win just like ultimate teams do every spring, but he also sold his players on a philosophy- He could be trusted to do what was best for the school, for the team and for each and every player. In the world of college football, that is rare to this do.

Holtz has many quotes about his time as coach and on leadership, but his quote (about what players want/expect from a team and coach) is my absolute favorite:

Coach Holtz advises that players ask the following three questions to evaluate your leadership:
  • "Can I trust you?
  • Are you committed to excellence?
  • Do you care about me?"
Coach Holtz developed three subsequent rules and expectations he has used in his role as a leader:
  • Do the right thing
  • Do the best that you can
  • Show people you care.
If you use this advice as a team leader in ultimate, you're really offering your players more than a place on a roster. You've built a team and a culture that people want to stay with and people want to join. Too often we've seen teams add players to the team for family/relationship reasons and cut more deserving players. We've seen good players get away with too much, and players not know where they stand with the captain/coach. We've also seen players question what the goals are and how the team is progressing. All these problems can be answered with leadership that makes people know they will be taken care of, and need only focus on their task and job.

A very simple leadership guide for long term gain both on and off the field.

Monday, April 20, 2009

Will the Lady GEE GEES gallop to the UPA College Championship?

Nation,

Here's a round-up of the Canadian schools that have played in this spring's UPA sectionals thus far.

While it seems that we have more mens teams entering into the series, it is yet again the women that offer our best hope to make the UPA College finals. Last year UBC won the championship and we wondered if we would get the chance to see a Canadian championship. UBC seems to have fallen back a bit this year but will be a favorite to return to the finals.

Ottawa's Lady Gee Gees seem to have taken a step forward this year. They enter regionals 18-1
with a major tournament win and an impressive showing at President's Day. They possess high end talent ( Anne Mercier, Kate Crump, Alex Benedict) and a "supporting cast" that could be the stars on many college teams (Sam Morris, Sonia Komendia, Kathryn Pohran, etc).

Can Ottawa win? It seems very possible but their major competition will come from the following:

California-Santa Barbara- Ottawa beat them head to head 15-11 at Centex
Stanford- 1-1 versus UBC, and lost to Ottawa in only matchup.
Oregon- Have beaten every team they have faced except Santa Barbara

As fans, we await the results to happen and hope, for a second year, we have a canadian team at the top of the UPA college podium.


Womens
UBC
Bellingham Invite- 1-3 record Pres Day Invitational 2009- 4-4 record The Stanford Invite- 2-5 record Women's College Centex 2009- 6-1 record (15-3 loss to Ottawa)
Wash/BC College Women's Sectionals- 6-2 record, finished 2nd and qualified for regionals

Ottawa
Pres Day Invitational 2009- 6-1 record, two forfeits Women's College Centex 2009- 7-0, champions Upstate NY College Women's Sectionals- 5-0 record, champions and advance to regionals


Men's
UBC
Trouble in Vegas- 6-3 record
Standford Invite- 2-4 Record
Wash/BC College Open Sectionals- 5-2 record, finished 3rd and qualified for regionals

Carleton University
Queen City Tune-Up 2K9- 2-4 Record
Spring Phling- 4-2 record
Roll Call, D.C.- 2-0 record, missing data
Upstate NY College Open Sectionals- 3-2 record, finsihed 3rd and qualified for regionals

Toronto
Michigan College Open Sectionals- 2-3 (did not qualify for regionals)

Waterloo
Michigan College Open Sectionals- 3-4 record, (did not qualify for regionals)

* Waterloo beats Toronto 11-2 in the 3rd place sunday bracket.. marking the first time in at least five years Toronto loses to Waterloo)

Dalhousie


East New England College Open Sectionals- 4-3 record, forfeits third place game and regionals opportunity. (Would be interesting to know what happened).

Queens
College Easterns 2009- 4-2
Did not enter into sectionals

Western
Double down tournament champions (Deafeats Michigan. Michigan State)
Did not enter into sectionals.

Wednesday, April 1, 2009

The Huddle is Fantastic...Here comes the BUT


Nation,

The Huddle online magazine is great for ultimate. Both in terms of quality and quantity of ultimate frisbee content.

One recent issue/theme was about role players. As a role player, this seems like yet another great issue idea.

Despite the fact that all of the authors are anything but role players in ultimate, I once again find the articles very good reads. They throw in some conventional wisdoms and the odd cliche, but generally their experiences in ultimate let them shed some tips that the readers (who want to improve in the game and want to hear from those that excel on the field) covet.

One of these articles got posted on my local leagues open forum. Charles Reznikoff's 'What Is A Role Player?' drew praise from a local aspiring player. Indeed, it is a good article, but for one major sentence that irked me.

One of my first captains saw me working tirelessly to fix my weaknesses. "Don't do that," he said. "Spend 70% of your energy improving your strengths." He was right. I'll never win a game jumping.

Huh? Let me get this straight. You're going to suggest to all aspiring players out there to ignore their own weaknesses and focus more on what you're already strong at.

This might work in baseball, where a player can focus on their offence or on their defence. Pitchers work more on their pitches However, ultimate is a HIGHLY organic game, where players have to do everything in order to play a point. You can't just play offence or defence. You can't just mark or jump.

There is a lot of good stuff to take from this article. However, if you're imparting advice or trying to determine how your team can improve its fate and the individual fate of its players, I want (as a guy that humbly tries to geek it up in the sport econ , sabrmetric and sport intelligence realms) to remind you of this:

  • A sample size of you or your team isn't necessarily good enough to summarize what works and what doesn't
In similar organic sports (hockey, basketball etc) many people try to find the link between winning and certain parts of the game (in our case, hucks, blocks, marks, you name it). What it really comes down to is this: The only statistically significant factor in winning at such games is to score more than the other team does, and your overall efficiency at playing the game and all of ts components is the key.

So please, get your role players to work on their weaknesses more than 30% of their practice time. Keep reading the huddle and listening to the stars, but remember to take their tips with a grain of salt.

Monday, March 30, 2009

The GAIA Close OUT Sale

Nation,

It is unlikely, but if you haven't heard, I have some very sad news to report. As reported on this site, GAIA is going out of business and having a clear out sale of all gear.

Regrettably, I think I have missed out on an item that I always wanted - A GAIA ultimate bag. Always wanted one and put it off due to price. I definitely purchased many a jersey, cleat and hat from the company, but held off on the one item people seemed to love having.

Do you have an GAIA regrets? Was there an item you always wanted and didn't get? Or, did you experience cognitive dissonance from buying a GAIA product that didn't last, didn't feel right or didn't live up to the price paid?

Thursday, March 19, 2009

March Madness- Something to Learn From

Nation,

It's the NCAA division one basketball tournament. March Madness, as I am sure most of you know full well. Most of my readers are from North America and have their own brackets and pool predictions. (Note: My overseas readership is at the point that I may have to reach out for some articles as a way of saying thanks)

I personally love this part of the tournament, when unknown players and teams upset heavily favored stars. Players draft values will be heavily weighted based on a mere 1-4 performances on this tournament. Players like Sean May (pictured) can play/win their way into the first round of the NBA draft, despite the fact that they clearly lack the NBA body for their position. Likewise, good players can have a bad game and be tainted.

Back to ultimate, watching the Madness today I wonder the following:
  1. Why are upsets much more common in the NCAA than in CUC or UPAs? Maybe I need to do some research and might be way off, but it seems UNC or Memphis could fall a lot easier than GOAT or Furious
  2. Do you think that CUPA should set up non-betting bracket challenges for CUC and CUUC? Would you welcome this challenge and do you think it would be popular?

Thursday, March 12, 2009

CUPA is now accepting bids to host CUC, CUUC and CEUUC


Nation, As per the CUPA site, please distribute to the organizers of your league(s)

______________________________________________________________
CUPA is now accepting bids to host CUC, CUUC & CEUUC

CUPA is seeking bids to host the 2010 Canadian Ultimate Championship (August 2010), the 2009 Canadian University Ultimate Championships (October 2009) & the 2009 Canadian Eastern University Ultimate Championships (Fall 2009). All completed bids should be sent to ed AT canadianultimate.com or mailed to CUPA, 200 Main St., Winnipeg, MB, R3C 4M2 by May 4, 2009.

2010 Canadian Ultimate Championships: Bid Proposal, CUPA-TOC Responsibilities

2009 Canadian University Ultimate Championships: Bid Proposal, CUPA-TOC Responsibilities

2009 Canadian Eastern University Ultimate Championships: Bid Proposal, CUPA-TOC Responsibilities

Note: If you would like to bid on both CUUC & CEUUC, one bid can be submitted with relevant differences included.

Wednesday, March 11, 2009

I'd rather be a fringe sport than a Canadian National Soccer Player...


Nation,

Interesting article from Jeters about talking about your ultimate life in your professional setting.
I have had good and bad experiences talking about our sport in various avenues (different cities, different workplaces, and with other sport academics). I was sometimes surprised by the respect given by high ranking people in sport (some of my colleagues with the COC for example) and I was also surprised by the ignorance from high level athletes and even some of my past sport management professors at Western.

I remember one particular prof who remarked that it was "great how (I) was such a defender of fringe sports". Her perception of fringe sports shocked me. Needing to pass her course, I declined to mention that her sport of choice (canadian university women's athletics) probably doesn't rank in the top ten of most respected sports either. How could someone that probably received a lifetime of rude comments about her gender's ability and sport itself turn around and be as equally rude and dismissive?

I think the harshest people of ultimate are those
  • Who don't know the sport
  • Who play other sports
  • Who play other sports that compete in an uphill battle to justify their existence for government monies
Nothing turns other sports against other sports like a fight for money and support. For some reason, sport never seems to work together when it is optimal.

The next time someone who plays soccer tries to tell you how great their sport is in Canada and how many people play the game compared to our "fringe sport", be sure to counter with our world ranking in the senior mens level.

We're now 94th in the world. "Sandwiched between Mozambique and Democratic Republic of the Congo."

Soccer Canada is an interesting example of what CUPA should strive to avoid. Politics have lead to inaction and mismanagement. That our nation, with all the facilities, programs, and clubs available with the time and money allowing kids to play, is sandwiched between two countries whose major concerns revolve around basic necessities for its people, drug wars, and avoiding civil war is well.. sad.

Kids play till their teens and then drop out at an alarming rate. Players like Owen Hargraves get passed over for someone's son and then shows up on England's starting lineup. Yet, Soccer Canada hides behind participation numbers.