Thursday, May 21, 2009

UPA College Finals 2009- It's Go Time!


Nation,

UPA college finals begins this Friday.

Men's bracket is here

Women's bracket is here

I've already made my observations as follows:

Team USA versus College All Star Alums- Who will win?

Factoid that Might Only be Interesting to me and Peter King

Comparison of RRI, UPA Top 25 and Actual Open Finals Participants

UPA College Finals-Teams Determined.

But I want to hear from you! Who will win each division? Will the winners be top four finalists from last year? How will Ottawa do?

Best of luck to our Gee Gee ladies... bring the ladies title back to Canada for a second year in a row!

Sunday, May 17, 2009

Revisting the 2005 CUC Semi-Final

Nation

The Test Subject- 2005 CUC Semi Final- Phoenix versus Nomads

Phoenix in 2005 (Ottawa Open Team) was considered a strong candidate to wing CUC 2005. The team had managed to stock their roster with every single local talent they had coveted for years, and looked to be a very strong young team with lots of speed, athleticism and exciting talent.

Coming off their first Ontario Regionals victory against Toronto rivals GOAT, nationals seemed like an exciting opportunity, and the team made no secret that they expected to be in the open finals are the very least.

It didn't happen. The team lost in the semis to a Victoria Team (Nomads). Nomads seemed like an older team that had some very skilled players, but would be challenged physically by the Phoenix squad. Looks can be deceiving.

I went through the entire game, play by play, pass by pass and took individual stats for each and every player to find out what went wrong.

Results

I collected the following:
• Individual Points ( o or d)
• throw attempts
• throw completions
• dump attempts
• dump made
• short throw attempts (anything up field that collects less than 10 yards)
• short throw completions
• medium throw attempt (anything 10-30 yards)
• medium throw made
• Hucks attempted (30 plus yards)
• Hucks made
• Special throw attempts and made
• Catches (and the type of catch if layout, sky, etc)
• Total Turns (with separate fields for throw, catch, etc)
• Fouls Called On
• Fouls Called Against
• Thrown Goals (and fields for type)
• Caught Goals (and fields for type)

Here's what I can say with certainty

• The offence (o line and d line) had some memorable turns, but their efficiency in the wind was pretty impressive. They completed over 89% of total throws. However, they struggled with hucks (45% including one player going a perfect 3 for 3) but even more so with medium throws (7 turns and 68% effectiveness)
• Almost all the team turnovers were unforced throwaways and only 0.5 could be attributed to the receiver.
• I was very surprised by the lack of turnovers forced by the Phoenix defense. They forced only 3 turnovers (one of them from an o line player on an o point) in the entire game. With the players involved, you would have a very hard time believing this.
• Just calculating who scored the goals and got assists would have given a much different picture from who were the most efficient players on offence.
• One starting player had as many turnovers as points, and made 40% of his throws. He actually had more turns than catches. That's hard to do, but it looks like the team recognized this good player was having an off day and made a change quick
Summary

A very interesting game that had a disappointing end for the Ottawa team. Looking at the Nomads team before the game, one would be hard pressed to think they were the better team. However, you're minds eye lies. The Nomads ended up beating GOAT in the finals to win nationals.

Nomads (despite the disgraceful hammer and sickle logo) were a very efficient offensive team in 2005. They didn't cause the turnovers that every team thinks of championship teams creating. They never blocked, layout d or skyed Phoenix. Instead, they are a bunch of experienced players that are "good at ultimate". They limit opportunities, don't take many fouls (5 all game) and score when they get the disc.

Using Video for Ultimate Stats and Analysis


Nation,

I've long said that video was the next step in better understanding the game of ultimate and the value of players on a given team/level.

Why video? The game can be better explained from more than just scores and player goals and assists. That is a small part of the bigger picture teams can use to better evaluate their team/opponents. The more data and games you can collect, the more meaningful your data. It is still impossible to perfectly predict future results, but you can create an arbitrage and understanding of what you need to do to win.

Based on my master thesis on the NHL, I certainly have an interest in bringing some form of better stats to ultimate. Also, my involvement in the game as a player also inspires me. If there is a link between stats and ultimate wins, I want to find it. (hypothesis is still that all around efficiency is the best predictor of success)

I can think a specific incident last year where my open team had a injured player from our open program (a very respect player of considerable reputation of perceived talent) took stats while watching us play a tournament. This person took these primitive stats ( number of points, goals. assists, turns) and made some "conclusions" about players (one defensive player in particular) which eventually made an influence in how that player was treated and seen on the depth chart all season. So, because this player wasn't flashy and didn't fit the prototype, all it took was some poor stats from a small sample to seal his fate. I'd really like to do something to help prevent those kinds of things happening.

People have experimented taking their own stats and using a palm pda on site to take stats as they go. However, I think the time constraints and speed of the game leave these methods susceptible to stat errors and omissions. Video is the way to go.

What are our current restraints?
  • Not a lot of games are done in full and available for viewing. You have to videotape your own games
  • I now realize that it takes 3-4 hours to watch a game and decode it for both offense and defensive stats. You need to have several players on a team helping to decode it with the same legend guide.. because it takes time and effort.
  • We don't have organized leagues and stats from each team that would allow us to compute the average of teams and players, and use that to determine how players mark up versus the average player at his/her position.

This was one of the few weekends that I had free time on the weekend. I finally decided to put my money where my mouth was and test out data collection via video.

The next post is my first venture. After my first game decode/transcribe, I feel even more confident that teams willing to videotape their games and break down the footage can learn something about their opponents, and much more about themselves

Friday, May 15, 2009

Friday Afternoon Thoughts

Nation,
  • I just saw a Blockstack episode on Paganello. I officially want to go next year.
  • I hate that blogger corrects every British spelling of words.. colour vs color...
Hope everyone has a great long weekend.

Is the Callahan Award Just a Popularity Contest?


Nation,

One of the best ultimate sites in the world, The Huddle, has posted an article about the Callahan award. An annual award given to the best male and female college player, it's an excellent award and should be a huge honour to anyone who has the chance to be nominated/awarded the prize.

Not only is the award a good thing, but the discussion and voting process is also good for the game of ultimate. It's nice when people are looking for the good players on their teams and on other squads. Those that go out of their way to nominate and advocate others are definitely to be saluted.

Here comes the but...

BUT with so many teams and so many players, combined with so little stats in the game of ultimate, how is the Callahan Award system anything but a popularity contest? I know we are following in the footsteps of pro sports, where sports writers are usually charged with the task of voting for MVP. Usually there is a lot of bickering over the definition of the MVP and the stats that most writers really don't understand.

I'm not saying the winners are not good players. Generally ultimate people can pick out the fast, the strong, and the spectacular play makers. However, winning a Callahan award involves the following keys

  • You have to play on a good team and get exposure
  • You have to have good champions to lobby for you
  • In most sports the scorers tend to get more love from MVP voters, and I assume ultimate is no different. So you have to be a big thrower or scorer.. and that's more important than being efficient and truly the most valuable
  • As with the case in all aspects in human life, it would not hurt to "look the part".
Despite all these issues with the award, I wouldn't want to see the Callahan award cease to exist. If we can improve our evaluation process as the game advances, it would be great. In the meantime, we'll keep watching the highlight clips, reading the campaigns and pick MVP needles from the proverbial haystack.

Thursday, May 14, 2009

Team USA versus College All Star Alums- Who will win?

Nation,

At the UPA College Finals. Team USA (World Games 2009 version) will face off against a team of College Alumni that once dominated the UPA college finals in their respective times. I personally am a fan of these all star games, and I'm glad to see a canadian named to the alumni team (Kate Crump).

Team USA Roster

College All Stars Alumni Roster

Rec.sport.disc tried to discuss this matchup, but fell victim to flammers/slaggers who usually subvert everything useful on that site.

Who do you think will win this match? More importantly, how does our Team Canada match up against the Team USA squad?

Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Contesting a Foul call on CUPA?


Nation,

To be well known in ultimate, you need to play for a long time, be good at the game, and have a very distinct/passionate personality. For these reasons, Greg Lang is famous... or infamous... however you want to put it. Seriously, fewer people are as well known for their amazing hucks and ability to play when motivated. If you're playing Lang, I highly suggest you don't bug him. It does your team absolutely no good.

Mr Lang recently participated in the Toronto Ultimate Festival and watched Team Canada's World Games team scrimmage with some of Toronto's best players. He was very disappointed to see that almost all of the Team Canada roster is open and womens players and not coed players. He was so angry that he wrote a late night rant on his local league open forum and has called a violation on CUPA.

Brett Taylor at No Borders 2008
Photo Courtesy Dave Knowles

Violation on CUPA?

"CUPA has yet again selected non co-ed players to represent Canada in an international co-ed competition... Those men and women who choose to and dedicate themselves to the co-ed game of ultimate in Canada are the only Canadian players who should be eligible to represent our country in that division internationally."

As a board member of CUPA, I feel the need to speak to this. Here are my thoughts:
  • I don't mind Greg Lang or anyone else having an opinion and expressing it regarding CUPA decisions or team selections.
  • I'm not sure posting on open forums of local leagues is the best way to reach CUPA, and doing it long after team selection is a little reactive.
  • I completely disagree with Gregs violation call (I can't contest a violation) and his idea on how International coed squads should be put together.
Greg's idea, as I understand it, is that only Co-ed players should be considered for coed national teams. Instantly, we are limiting the talent that we can pick from, and we are discriminating againsts players and teams who may only be able to play for men's and women's teams in their area. How do we determine who is really a coed player and who is not? This could get messy.

CUPA is really trying to improve its processes for competitive play and team selection. Events such as World Games (the national team in selection) is a small rostered event that will feature the best players from the best countries. We worked very hard to recruit a talented selection committee (Andrew Lugsdin, Jeff Cruickshank, Eva Cham, Sherri Madigan, Lara Mussell) to try and cover all division across the country and put forward a winning team based on lessons learned from past World Games experiences.

It doesn't make it right, but when one looks at the Team USA roster, we see a similar trend in open/women player selection for the World Games roster. I do think that the overall best players are in the open/women's divisions, but I also hope that Team USA has not missed out on any hidden coed gems. It's Canada's gain if they did.

I want to see the best players picked for national teams, regardless of division, location, politics or gender. I think the entire CUPA board also echos that sentiment, and we're trying to make that happen on national team at a time.